The “Public Interest”

No matter which party or politician backs a particular piece of legislation, its advocates nearly always proclaim that it serves the public interest. And opponents are just as quick to claim that the legislation is harmful to the public interest. The Keystone XL pipeline serves as an example.

For years, the pipeline was a controversial issue. Critics claimed that the pipeline did not serve the public interest. Jane Kleeb, president of the Bold Alliance, one of the Keystone XL’s leading opponents, told the Nebraska Public Utility Commision, “We have the evidence on our side that this pipeline does not meet the public interest of Nebraska.” Proponents responded that the pipeline would reduce dependence on oil from the Middle East and create jobs—both of which it argued was in the public interest. Union members favored building the pipeline.

But attorney Brian Jorde said, “The main question is not farmers versus union members. We also support union members and jobs. The threshold question is: Is this project in the public interest of Nebraska? And it’s not.” Which side is correct? Is the pipeline in the public interest or not?

While both sides bickered over what is and isn’t in the public interest, neither bothered to define what constitutes the public interest. And Keystone is hardly the only example. The reason that nobody bothers to define the public interest is quite simple—the term can’t be defined.

The American public consists of more than 330 million people. Some are gay and some are straight. Some are male and some are female. Some are white and some are Hispanic, black, Asian, and other ethnicities or races. Some are Christian, some are Jewish, some are Muslim, and some are atheists. Some like baseball and some like ballet. In short, the American public is not monolithic. It consists of individuals with a wide range of characteristics, values, and interests. To proclaim that a particular policy or program serves the public interest is to ignore this vast diversity of values and interests.

In practice, the public interest means that the interests of some individuals take precedence over the interests of others. Some individuals will be forced to sacrifice for the alleged benefit of others.

It is not surprising then, that groups seek to curry favor with politicians and bureaucrats. Groups seek to influence the policy makers who wield tremendous power over individuals and businesses. Those groups want favorable legislation and regulations, and they are willing to trade political support for those government favors.

Similar Posts

  • Caught in the Crossfire

    When government expands its powers beyond its legitimate purpose of protecting individual rights, unintended consequences are unleashed. When various levels of government use those powers for different goals, the individual is invariably caught in the crossfire. Government’s response to the pandemic is one example. Early in the pandemic, states and localities across the nation ordered…

  • Cronyism in Cedar Park

    The Dallas Morning News reports that government officials in Cedar Park recently approved a plan to create a special tax zone in the city’s downtown area. The plan is expected to generate $160 million in investments in the area. Such tax zones are used throughout the state to generate funds to improve the infrastructure in…

  • An Insensitive A-hole

    Even in normal times, it can be extremely difficult to make certain statements without being considered an insensitive a-hole. In these days of a pandemic, that has become even more true. Those who question the government’s actions are quickly labeled as caring more about money than people. But sometimes such statements need to made if…

  • Rebel Against the Tyrants

    For nearly two months, Americans have allowed government to shut down businesses, destroy jobs, and wreck the economy. For nearly two months, Americans have tolerated an unprecedented destruction of values. This isn’t a new occurrence in American history. In the 18th century Great Britain enacted a series of laws that shut down businesses, destroyed jobs…

  • The Onion Files Amicus Brief

    The Onion, which calls itself “America’s Finest News Source,” recently filed an amicus brief with the United States Supreme Court in defense of Anthony Novac. In 2016, the aspiring comic created a parody of the Parma, Ohio, Police Department’s Facebook page. He was subsequently arrested and charged with “disrupting police operations.” The Onion’s brief brilliantly…

  • |

    Unattractive Alternatives isn’t Force

    A report published in The Atlanta Journal-Constitution claims that landlords force renters to sign away their rights. The report details provisions in a standard lease that offer unattractive options to tenants and asserts that this is an act of force. The truth is, having to choose between unattractive alternatives isn’t force. As an example, the…