Compromise in St. Paul

On November 2, voters in St. Paul approved a referendum to enact the nation’s most stringent rent control law. The city government was unprepared, and in the ensuing weeks dissension has been fomenting in the city as developers announce that projects are being put on hold.

On one side are tenants and their advocates. They believe that might makes right, that the will of the majority is supreme. On the other side are city officials. They believe that the measure adopted by voters is too restrictive and seek a compromise between tenants and developers.

The president of the Housing Justice Center said that developer concerns about the ordinance are speculative. “Is there a real issue that is based on facts, data and information?” she asked.

I can’t speak for the developers, but the approval of price controls on landlords is a “real issue that is based on facts.” The referendum makes no exceptions for new development, which means that developers face great uncertainty regarding the ability to recover their investment. Developers already face significant risks. When voters can arbitrarily and unilaterally dictate how they can operate their business, developers have every reason to be cautious.

City officials are still trying to figure out what the rent control ordinance means and how to enforce it. Though they have expressed concerns about the ordinance’s impact on new development, they hope to find a compromise between freedom and slavery. The city’s planning director said,

We’ll be inviting stakeholders, stakeholder groups, starting with city council, to earnestly participate in the conversation that doesn’t pit renters against landlords, doesn’t pit growth against equity and affordability.

City officials think that there is some middle ground between housing producers and those who want to shackle and control them. But there is no such middle ground. If developers accept any form of rent control, they will be accepting shackles and controls. They might gain some temporary reprieve, but they will have lost the war. Compromise might reduce the extent of the controls for the time being. But compromise will empower advocates to lobby for more draconian measures in the future.

For example, if developers accept rent control, but ask that new construction be exempted for a period of time (15 years is common), they will have no valid argument to argue against further restrictions in the future. The time frame for the exemption could be shortened or completely eliminated if voters choose to do so in the future.

Neither voters nor city council has a moral right to impose rent control on landlords. If property owners want the freedom to produce housing, they must reject rent control in any form. They must proudly stand firm and refuse to compromise.

Similar Posts

  • Socialized Roads Destroy Affordable Housing

    In my book, The Affordable Housing Crisis: Causes and Cures, I examine how socialized roads have impacted the affordability of housing. A real-life example is currently taking place as the government attempts to expand Interstate 45 through downtown Houston. The project will result in the displacement of 1,079 homes, 2 schools, 5 churches, and 344…

  • Freedom of Choice

    Housing advocates are promoting two bills before the Texas legislature (HB1470 and SB265) in the name of freedom of choice. But these bills are not about freedom of choice. The two bills would make it illegal for landlords to refuse to accept housing choice vouchers or other forms of financial aid for housing. This, we…

  • Experiments in Freedom

    Virtually every proposal to address the housing crisis starts with the same flawed premise, namely, the solution must come from government. The city of Boise illustrates this flawed premise. The city is currently testing three different ideas to address the housing shortage: incentives and assistance for homeowners to build an accessory dwelling unit (ADU), allowing…

  • Friday Roundup 6-11-21

    In an editorial, the Los Angeles Times has called for the federal government to dramatically expand its housing subsidy program (often called Section 8). Currently, the Los Angeles Housing Authority administers 58,000 Section 8 vouchers. However, the authority estimates that 600,000 vouchers are needed to provide vouchers to everyone who qualifies. If the Housing Authority…

  • |

    Property Wrongs

    A neighborhood association in Boise is fighting a proposal to develop a 226-unit subdivision. The Northwest Neighborhood Association (NWNA) contends that the development would prejudice its “substantial rights to ‘open space and rural character.’” Rights pertain to freedom of action. If one desires to live in a neighborhood with open space and a rural character,…

  • Friday Roundup 9-24-21

    In early September, New York extended its eviction moratorium to January 15, 2022. The state’s largest landlord group quickly challenged the law. The group said that the new moratorium made only superficial changes to a previous law that “crumbled” after a Supreme Court ruling. That ruling took issue with a part of the law that…