|

I Know What is Best for You

A good salesman seeks to empower his customer to make a wise purchasing decision. He does this by asking questions to determine the customer’s needs and desires. He can then direct the customer to the products and features that will be most satisfying. Bad salesmen, on the other hand, show no concern for what the customer needs or desires. He thinks that he knows what is best for the customer.

This type of patronizing attitude isn’t limited to salesmen. Those promoting political ideas often take the same approach. They tell the victims of their scheme that they—the advocates—know what is best for those who will be controlled and restricted. An example can be found at AmericanCityandCountry.com.

Scott McGill promotes the idea of periodic rental inspections by government authorities and argues that every city should adopt such a program. Not surprisingly, McGill works for 3Di Systems, a company that provides “ideas, education, and reflections for stronger communities.”

He writes, “Without periodic inspections, disrepair is an inevitability.” This is certainly true because you can’t fix what you don’t know is broken. But McGill implies that property owners do not conduct inspections on their own and must rely on government officials to tell them what needs repair. Property owners, he wants us to believe, don’t know what is in their own best interest. Government officials do.

If a property owner wants to maintain his rental housing—and most landlords do—then he will conduct periodic inspections. And he won’t wait the four years that McGill suggests for government inspections. If we adopted McGill’s proposal, a problem that develops a month after an inspection won’t be discovered for another four years. That will lead to the major repairs that McGill claims his program will avoid.

I appreciate good salesmen. They help me understand my options and which product will best serve my interests. However, a good salesman treats me like a rational adult and helps me decide what is best for me. A bad salesman acts as if he knows more about my desires and values than I do. He will then resort to manipulation, or in McGill’s case, government coercion to impose his conclusions on me.

Similar Posts

  • Experiments in Freedom

    Virtually every proposal to address the housing crisis starts with the same flawed premise, namely, the solution must come from government. The city of Boise illustrates this flawed premise. The city is currently testing three different ideas to address the housing shortage: incentives and assistance for homeowners to build an accessory dwelling unit (ADU), allowing…

  • A Lack of Consistency

    In the most recent legislative session, Texas lawmakers passed several bills intended to strengthen property rights. At the same time, they passed at least one bill that represents a gross infringement of property rights. That inconsistency indicates that legislators really don’t understand what the right to property means. Property rights protect our freedom to create,…

  • Cause and Effect

    The city of Houston recently enacted stricter regulations governing boarding houses. The Houston Chronicle reported that: The ordinances — prompted by several fires in unregulated and unsafe multi-resident housing facilities over the last year — follow months of meetings between city officials and community groups and wrangling between city agencies. The purported goal of the…

  • |

    Repeal not Revision

    In cities across the nation, zoning laws are being revised to allow duplexes, fourplexes and other small multifamily housing in areas previously restricted to single-family homes. The argument behind these measures is that fewer government controls and restrictions on development will spur the construction of more affordable housing. The argument is correct, but relaxing land-use…