|

Might Doesn’t Make Right

Politicians are often exhorted to follow the “will of the people”—to take those actions that are supported by a majority of citizens. This is a very dangerous idea because it can justify virtually any kind of injustice.

To illustrate this, consider a recent article in the Summit Daily in Colorado. The article states that “most Colorado voters think the state has an affordable housing problem and want the government to intervene to solve it, a recent poll shows.” The poll also found strong support for policies such as rent control and forcing developers to include more affordable housing in their projects.

We will leave aside the issue of whether a survey of 508 registered voters in a state of 5.8 million people truly reflects the views of all Coloradans. The relevant issue here is whether the views of the majority should be coercively imposed on the minority.

Let us assume for a moment, that the poll had asked about views regarding homosexuality. Let us also assume that the poll found that “most” Colorado voters support making homosexuality illegal and throwing offenders in jail. (And you can substitute any activity for homosexuality.) The fact that a majority of citizens support a policy doesn’t make it proper or just.

The “will of the people” means that the majority rules. It means that the majority can vote for policies that are grossly unjust. And such policies are “justified” because they represent the “will of the people.”

Truth is not determined by a vote. Might doesn’t make for good public policy nor does it make a particular policy right.

Those who participate in polls, including voting, are not necessarily qualified to comment on the issue at hand. For example, both tenants and landlords have experience with rental housing. But property owners, landlords, and developers have actual experience in producing housing and the challenges of doing so. Housing producers are far more qualified than tenants to comment on the appropriate way to address the affordable housing crisis.

However, there are far more tenants than landlords. And if we adhere to the “will of the people,” then tenants and their supporters can vote to impose controls and restrictions on landlords. But the fact that tenants might have political might doesn’t mean the policies they support are right.

Similar Posts

  • Exacerbating the Problem

    Progressive Regressive “journalist” Patrick Range McDonald informs us that renters paid a total of $512 billion to landlords in 2019. This, he wants us to believe, is evidence of “corporate landlord greed.” Certainly, that’s a lot of money. However, it proves nothing other than McDonald’s inability to consider the full context. In doing so, he…

  • A Crime to Judge

    In mid-June, New Jersey joined the ranks of jurisdictions making it illegal for landlords to discriminate against convicted criminals. Because of the large percentage of convicted criminals who are “people of color,” the law is being hailed as a reform of the criminal justice system and a step toward racial equity. The law prohibits landlords…

  • |

    Jim Crow Redux

    In the late 19th and early 20th century, a series of laws were enacted, primarily in Southern states, that mandated racial segregation. Blacks and whites could not stay in the same hotel, eat in the same dining room, or ride in the same railroad car. Interracial marriage was forbidden, and blacks could not own or…

  • Those Who don’t Learn from History…

    Swedish economist Assar Lindbeck once asserted, “In many cases rent control appears to be the most efficient technique presently known to destroy a city—except for bombing.” Economists disagree on many things, but almost universally agree that rent control is a bad idea. But this hasn’t stopped politicians and housing advocates from calling for more rent…

  • |

    Friday Roundup 10-22-22

    Charlie Simms, the owner of a development company in Ohio, makes a point that needs to be included in discussions regarding affordable housing. Housing advocates consider affordable housing to mean below market rate housing. However, as Simms writes, “When builders and developers speak of affordable housing we’re talking about how to build homes that the…