“State’s Rights” Versus Local Control

Former Arlington mayor Richard Greene isn’t happy with the state legislature. He decries the state’s efforts to restrict what local governments can do, and laments the fact that state legislators are thinking about shutting down the Texas Municipal League. That organization, he claims, works “to protect individual rights to develop the communities where they live the way they want.” He goes on to claim that the efforts of state legislators are a “usurpation of your personal liberty.”

Greene is either very confused or very dishonest.

Individual rights protect the freedom of individuals–each individual–to live as he chooses, so long as he respects the freedom of others to do the same. But Greene’s only concern regarding individuals is their ability to influence legislators.

It is much easier, he writes, for individuals to influence local legislators than state legislators. If you want “something to happen in your community or if you want to stop something from happening,” it is much easier to accomplish that on the local level. To Greene, the nature of that “something” is irrelevant. If you can convince local legislators to pass a law, the state should not interfere. The citizens of a community should be allowed to pass whatever laws they desire.

Interestingly, conservative state legislators have used the same argument against the federal government. They have claimed that states should be permitted to pass laws reflecting the desires and values of the citizens of that state–so-called “state’s rights.”

According to the advocates of “state’s rights,” if a state wants to ban homosexual sex, it should be permitted to do so. According to the advocates of local control, if a city wants to ban short-term rental properties, it should be permitted to do so. Despite the issues that they choose to focus on, the two sides agree on fundamental ideas.

Both the advocates of “state’s rights” and the advocates of local control believe that the group should be permitted to impose its values upon the rest of the citizenry. They simply disagree on which group should do the imposing. But in the end, the individual is victimized. The individual is forced to subordinate his values to the group.

“State’s rights” versus local control is a false dichotomy. The real issue is individual liberty versus subservience to the group.

Similar Posts

  • Democracy and Libraries

    This was originally posted on Live Oaks on July 12, 2010. Comments have not been migrated. In an effort to balance their budgets, cities across the nation are reducing the money they spend on public libraries. Not surprisingly, the Chronicle finds this “alarming”: For Americans of limited means, and that includes many Houstonians, public libraries…

  • |

    TLC Thinks Some Consumers are Stupid

    The Texas Lottery Commission (TLC) is suing a Houston-area distiller for trademark infringement. The commission owns a trademark on the phrase “Texas Two Step.” The distiller wants to market a handmade vodka called “Texas Two Step.” But that is where the similarities end. Trademarks do not prohibit others from using a phrase. They do prohibit…

  • Cronyism is Fascism

    Cronyism is the practice of dispensing political favors to some at the expense of others. Those with the proper political connections are the beneficiaries. Those who provide electoral support through donations or votes are rewarded with favorable legislation. Fascism is a form of collectivism, as are socialism and communism. In each of these systems, the…

  • Let it Be

    There are many people who can’t let it be. They can’t accept the fact that others may disagree with them or make choices that they don’t think rational. And rather than let it be, they seek to force others to live by their choices and values. To let it be means to accept the fact…

  • |

    The Whole Truth

    The headline for a recent article on CNBC.com declares, “The 7 most affordable U.S. states to retire—and none of them are Florida” illustrates the intellectual dishonesty that is prevalent in today’s media. The article states that Michigan is the most affordable state in which to retire according to a study issued by Bankrate. This is…