Wanna Bet?

The recent Supreme Court ruling striking down a federal law that prohibited most states from allowing betting on sporting events was a double-edged sword. While it struck down a right-violating law, it will do nothing to prevent states from violating individual rights. According to CNN,

The court said the federal law violated constitutional principles limiting the federal government from controlling state policy, unconstitutionally forcing states to prohibit sports betting under their own laws.

In other words, the ruling didn’t come out in favor of individual rights. Instead, it supported “states’ rights.”

How an individual spends his money is nobody’s business but his. If he wants to spend his money betting on the ponies, dogs, in casinos, or on sporting events, he has a moral right to do so. It’s his money to do with as he chooses. Gambling is a choice, and individuals have a moral right to live as they choose, so long as they respect the rights of others to do the same.

Prohibitions on gambling, as well well as other voluntary actions, are improper and immoral. They force individuals to act, not as they choose, but as government officials decree. More importantly, government should not be passing laws that allow individuals to engage in voluntary, not rights-violating activities. That merely grants permission, and free individuals do not need permission.

The notion of “states’ rights” holds that states may properly pass whatever laws the citizens demand. If the citizens want laws that violate individual, according to the advocates of “states’ rights,” this is acceptable. But the purpose of government, at every level, is the protection of individual rights. If a local government passes laws that violate rights, such as imposing tree regulations or outlawing short-term rentals, it is property for the state to intervene and strike down such laws. It is equally appropriate for the federal government to strike down state laws that violate rights.

Rather than ruling that states can legalize sports betting, the Court should have ruled that no government, federal, state, or local, can ban the practice.

Similar Posts

  • The Cause of Lobbying

    This was originally posted on Live Oaks on January 25, 2010. Comments have not been migrated. Last week’s Supreme Court ruling regarding corporate contributions to political campaigns has statists of all persuasions up in arms. The Chronicle, for example, editorialized: With this action, the court has effectively undermined the influence of individuals and parties on…

  • Let States Become Theocracies

    In his concurring opinion on Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, Justice Clarence Thomas has indicated that he would let states become theocracies. Thomas wrote, “In future cases, we should reconsider all of this Court’s substantive due process precedents, including Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell.” The ruling in Griswold struck down Connecticut’s ban on contraception. In…

  • |

    TLC Thinks Some Consumers are Stupid

    The Texas Lottery Commission (TLC) is suing a Houston-area distiller for trademark infringement. The commission owns a trademark on the phrase “Texas Two Step.” The distiller wants to market a handmade vodka called “Texas Two Step.” But that is where the similarities end. Trademarks do not prohibit others from using a phrase. They do prohibit…

  • The Freedom to Choose

    Both “progressives” and conservatives speak about the freedom to choose. Yet, they do so very selectively. They adamantly support an individual’s freedom to choose in regard to some issues, and then are equally adamant in opposing an individual’s freedom to choose in regard to other issues. For example, “progressives” support an individual’s freedom to choose…