Ninotchka

Sadly, contemporary comedic movies usually offer us a boring combination of juvenile antics and crude language. Fortunately, when we want light-hearted entertainment, we are not limited to the offerings of modern film makers. Technology allows us to enjoy some the cinematic gems of the past. And Ninotchka is one of those gems.

Greta Garbo is Nina Ivanovna “Ninotchka” Yakushova. In one of her last roles, Garbo presents two very starkly different views of the individual within a single movie.

At the beginning of the movie, Ninotchka is a stern Soviet emissary, sent to Paris to negotiate the sale of Czarist jewels that were “legally confiscated.” Her primary concern is obtaining the maximum price for the jewels because the money is needed to feed the Soviet people. While in Paris, she also hopes to learn more about the Western world, such as traffic control, the Eiffel Tower, and electricity generation.

Unbeknownst to her, she happens to meet the representative for the Grand Duchess whose jewels that Ninotchka is offering for sale. Hesitantly, she finds herself falling in love with the representative, even though she believes that love is individualistic and therefore improper for a Comrade to experience.

Ninotchka is torn between her devotion to the Revolution and her own desires. She experiences a conflict between her belief that individuals must serve some “higher cause” and her own personal values and happiness.

Esthetically, Ninotchka is a delight. Garbo is believable as a repressed servant of “the people.” And she is equally believable as she transforms into a woman who places her own happiness above “the people.”

Philosophically, Ninotchka is also a delight. It dramatizes the difference between living for others and living for oneself.

Though a comedy, Ninotchka presents a choice that is not a laughing matter. Our personal happiness depends on the choice we make. Ninotchka shows us the proper choice.

Similar Posts

  • The Innovator Versus the Collective

    My second book, The Innovator Versus the Collective, is now available in paperback and Kindle. The Introduction to the book is posted below. At the beginning of the Industrial Revolution in Great Britain, many textile workers rebelled against the labor-saving machines being introduced. The Luddites—as they were called—believed that this new technology would mean the…

  • Give Me Your Tired… Never Mind

    For one-hundred forty years, the Statue of Liberty has stood as a beacon for those aspiring for a better life in America. A plaque inside the statue’s pedestal declares: Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to…

  • The “Public Interest”

    No matter which party or politician backs a particular piece of legislation, its advocates nearly always proclaim that it serves the public interest. And opponents are just as quick to claim that the legislation is harmful to the public interest. The Keystone XL pipeline serves as an example. For years, the pipeline was a controversial…

  • Quality of Life

    We hear lots of talk from politicians and various organizations about improving the quality of life. But the quality of life advocates never define what they mean by the term. They assume that we all know, and agree to,  its meaning. More than 25 million people live in Texas. Some prefer the ballet over baseball….

  • The Crony Ideology

    Both leftists and conservatives embrace the crony ideology. That they apply that ideology differently is merely a matter of detail. So, what is the crony ideology? The essence of the crony ideology is the belief that government force should be used to compel or prohibit certain actions. Every act of cronyism ultimately rests on this…