|

Zoning or not, Here They Come

Government officials frequently cite the government’s police powers as a justification for their policies. While this can seem plausible in some situations, the City of Houston has decreed that this includes dictating what color individuals may paint their home.

This past week, the Texas Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Powell v. City of Houston. The case centers on the city’s preservation ordinance. The ordinance requires property owners in designated historic districts to obtain permission before making esthetic changes to their property.

The plaintiff contends that this is de facto zoning, which is prohibited by the city charter. The city argues that it isn’t. But no matter how the Court rules, the preservation ordinance is a violation of property rights. 

The right to property means the freedom to create, attain, use, trade, and keep material values. It means the freedom to manufacture widgets and sell them to willing buyers without first begging for permission from government officials. It means the freedom to buy those widgets and use them as one desires. And it means the freedom to paint one’s house the color of one’s choosing without groveling at the feet of bureaucrats for approval.

Like all rights, the right to property doesn’t not give one the freedom to violate the rights of others—to use one’s property in a way that prevents others from using their property as they choose. The color of one’s house—no matter how hideous—does not violate anyone’s rights. We may not want a neighbor to paint his house Putrid Pink, but if he does so our rights have not been violated.

That the city finds it necessary to meddle into such mundane issues as paint colors is a sign of our times. When government officials do not think us capable of making rational choices regarding paint colors, they certainly aren’t going to allow us the freedom to make decisions during a pandemic.

Similar Posts

  • A History Lesson

    Many Americans view history as little more than a collection of semi-interesting stories. History, they believe, has little bearing on contemporary life. They believe that that was then, and this is now. Times have changed. Viewed properly, history is an intellectual laboratory. We can trace the intellectual causes and motivations of events, movements, and individuals….

  • Friday Roundup 6-25-21

    City officials in Charleston, South Carolina want to pay homeowners to build accessory dwelling units (ADUs) on their property. Relaxing zoning regulations that limit or prohibit ADUs, also called granny flats or mother-in-law suites, is one way many cities are addressing the shortage of affordable housing. Ending the prohibition on ADUs is a proper step….

  • Nuisance and Zoning

    This was originally posted on Live Oaks on November 17, 2009. Comments have not been migrated. One of the primary justifications for zoning is to prevent “incompatible” land uses, such as keeping industrial facilities out of residential areas. Such “incompatible” uses are regarded as an inherent nuisance, and rather than wait for the nuisance to…

  • The CodeNext Debate: Gang Warfare

    I have previously written, albeit briefly, about both the economic and moral aspects of opposition to Austin’s CodeNext. The debate over the city’s proposed new land-use regulations is an example of the gang warfare that permeates modern American politics. On one side we have developers and their lobbyists. On the other side, we have community…