|

Tribalism on the Warpath

New York City is considering a law that will require “racial equity studies”—akin to environmental impact statements—for zoning changes. The law would require “a study that would analyze the area’s demographic conditions, quality of life, housing security and displacement risk index.”

One supporter of the law acknowledges that rezoning has provided great benefits, but only in certain areas of the city. He added,

In others, in communities of more color, they have helped spur gentrification and displacement. Both developers and the city have been reluctant to recognize the role of rezonings in this racial and ethnic displacement, much less take adequate action to prevent it.

If a racial equity study finds that a particular project will result in the displacement of “people of color,” it will be used as a club to beat developers into submission. Developers will be forced to abandon their project or concede to whatever demands activists and politicians can concoct.

Supporters don’t justify this law by claiming that rezoning violates anyone’s rights. Their justification is that rezoning might have results that some people don’t like, such as the displacement of “people of color.” And if “people of color” are disproportionately impacted, then rezoning is clearly wrong.

The law will extend certain political favors to the members of a particular group. Membership in that group is not determined by one’s actions, one’s character, or one’s values. Membership is determined by the color of one’s skin. Because of one’s skin color, according to this law, one should be protected from the undesirable. This is racism.

Ayn Rand noted that racism, like every form of collectivism, is a desire for the unearned. And that is precisely the goal of racial equity studies. Government officials will use these studies to extort concessions from developers in exchange for permission to proceed with a project. Those concessions will focus on minimizing or preventing the displacement of “people of color,” and most likely they will require the developer to provide subsidized housing to a substantial number of families. If the developer refuses, he will be denied permission to build his project.

The beneficiaries of these concessions will do nothing to earn whatever values come their way. Their only “claim” to those benefits is the color of their skin. Their only “claim” to those benefits is membership in the favored tribe. Sadly, New York City’s “people of color” are not the only ones seeking unearned values.

The desire for the unearned is growing in America with an increasing number of tribes seeking values that they have not earned. Low-skilled workers demand $15 an hour. College students demand free education. College graduates demand forgiveness of their student loan debt. Those on unemployment demand higher payments for a longer period of time. Each of these tribes is on the warpath, seeking to expropriate values from the producers.

Similar Posts

  • A House in a Box

    Many great innovations begin with an idea that others dismiss as absurd. The electric light bulb is one example. When Thomas Edison announced that he was working to invent an electric light bulb, he was mocked as a fool with no understanding of electricity. But he trusted his own judgment, and when he succeeded, he…

  • Balancing Power with a Gun

    Housing advocates frequently talk about the imbalance of power between landlords and renters. Their solution is to use brute force to provide a more “equitable” balance. This policy is founded on the premise that individuals should experience the same results, regardless of their actions or character. As an example, a growing number of jurisdictions are…

  • |

    Local Control Needs to be Controlled

    In November 2015, the Austin City Council passed a temporary moratorium on new licenses for Type 2, non-owner-occupied short-term rentals (STRs). A few months later, the moratorium was made permanent. At the same time, the city prohibited “assemblies” of more than six people between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m., effectively banning backyard cookouts and birthday…

  • A State of Denial

    In November 2021, voters in St. Paul approved one of the nation’s most stringent rent control laws. The law was later amended  to loosen the controls slightly. However, that did little to motivate the construction of new housing. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) reports that building permits in St. Paul fell…

  • |

    The Roundup 8

    The hypocrisy of many Republicans regarding the use of eminent domain to build Trump’s border wall has been pointed out by many. Sen. Michael Bennet (D–Colo.), recently took them to task on the floor of the Senate. ___ Texas legislators have introduced two bills that would allow property owners to be compensated for diminished property…

  • Profiteering and Property Taxes

    When a landlord raises the rent, he is often accused of profiteering—making an “excessive” or “unfair” profit. Those making such claims seldom present any evidence, other than pointing out that some corporate landlords generate billions in revenue. However, revenue is only one factor in determining profitability. Expenses—insurance, maintenance, mortgage payments, and property taxes—must also be…