The Roundup 2

The Echo Chamber
I have recently been giving a lot of thought to the “echo chamber”–the tendency of people to associate primarily with people who share their views. As a result, the information they receive on political issues generally conforms with their beliefs. It becomes a form of political tribalism. While studies have come to mixed conclusions about the number of people trapped in an echo chamber, almost nobody claims that it doesn’t exist. An echo chamber is certainly comfortable. One’s ideas aren’t challenged. One doesn’t need to think, question premises, examine new evidence. One can just spout tired bromides. It would seem that ignorance is indeed bliss.

Arguing vs. Discussing
Anyone interested in politics has undoubtedly engaged in a discussion that quickly turned into an argument. In the end, nobody has changed their mind and everyone is angry. A fundamental cause of this is the failure to identify common goals or values. Too often, we hear someone utter something, and we immediately respond with our disagreement. That is not an invitation for a conversation. It is an incitement for an argument. We fail to identify the goal that they seek to achieve. If we want to have discussions (and perhaps change minds), then we must first seek to find common goals and values. And they exist a lot more than we might think.

Similar Posts

  • Friday Roundup 7-9-21

    A lawsuit against the city of Chicago illustrates the adage, “it’s not what you know, it’s who you know.” In the early 2000s, Bloomer Chocolate wanted to expand its factory. The company offered the owner of an adjacent property $824,980 for the land. When the owner declined the offer, the city of Chicago seized the…

  • Friday Roundup 10-8-21

    In September, California passed SB 10, which allows cities to “upzone” and permit greater housing density in neighborhoods previously zoned for single-family homes. A “housing justice” organization, AHF, has filed a lawsuit that asserts “allowing legislators to override zoning restrictions violates the constitutional right of initiative by allowing local government to repeal or disregard initiative…

  • The Roundup 9

    The Guardian has an article on the border wall that touches on a deeper, and equally divisive issue: drug prohibition. A former customs agent is quoted: ” “You got to ask yourself: why are all the drugs and illegal immigrants coming through? Why? Because of the demand for illegal drugs and illegal labour, not much…

  • |

    Friday Roundup 5-14-21

    One of the latest trends in the “tenants’ rights” movement is to provide free legal representation for tenants facing eviction. Washington state has passed such a law and other states are considering doing so. As with nearly everything associated with “housing justice,” these laws will ultimately create a host of new problems. As one example,…

  • Friday Roundup 1-21-22

    Last week, the Supreme Court ruled that the Biden Administration did not have legislative authority to issue a mandate that employers with more than 100 workers require vaccination. The Court did not say that vaccine mandates are unconstitutional or a violation of individual rights. It simply said that Congress hasn’t authorized such a rights-violating mandate….

  • Friday Roundup 6-4-21

    The Texas General Land Office recently announced that it will be seizing private property along the Gulf Coast. Tropical storms in 2020 moved the tide lines along the coast, and according to the Texas open beach statutes, the state owns land from the average low tide line to the vegetation line. The result is that…