A Chilling Free Speech Case

In December 2021, sheriff’s deputies in Fort Bend County, Texas, arrested Justin Pulliam for interfering with a police officer. Justin had been filming the officers while they made a mental-health call. He was located 130 feet from the scene, where other bystanders were also watching what was happening. With the help of the Institute for Justice, Justin later sued the sheriff and several deputies. This is a chilling free speech case that could have repercussions far beyond Fort Bend County.

Justin is a “citizen journalist.” He is not a member of the recognized media, but an independent reporter of local government activities. He is often critical of government officials, including the Fort Bend County Sheriff’s Office. After filming deputies for years without problems, things changed when a new sheriff took office in January 2021.

The first incident occurred in July. Sheriff Eric Fagan was holding a press conference in a public park when he demanded that Justin be removed because he wasn’t a part of the local media. The intimidation culminated in Justin’s arrest in December. The arrest was filmed and is available on You Tube.

Political commentary, including criticizing government officials, is central to the protections offered by the First Amendment. Free speech means that one may express ideas without penalty from the government. Being arrested for expressing ideas—any ideas—is censorship.

If it is illegal to criticize government officials in Fort Bend County, would those criticize their city council or the board of education also be subject to arrest? Would I—a resident of Fort Bend County—be a criminal for writing this blog post?

The sheriff’s department claims that Justin was interfering with their activities. But that is just a pretense as the video clearly shows. The department doesn’t like what Justin has to say about him, and so, they seek to shut him up. If they can do that to Justin, they can do it to anyone in the county.

Similar Posts

  • Friday Roundup 2-4-22

    A Scottish man was recently convicted for sending a tweet that was deemed offensive. The tweet was disgusting, saying that the only good British soldier is a dead one. Freedom of speech protects our right to make offensive and disgusting statements. Rather than prosecute those who are intentionally offensive, we should recognize such statements for…

  • Anti-discrimination Laws are Anti-choice

    Discrimination means recognizing the difference between to or more things. Every choice that we make is an act of discrimination. To oppose discrimination is to oppose freedom of choice. Anti-discrimination laws are anti-choice. As an example, consider laws that prohibit “source of income” discrimination in housing. Such laws force landlords to accept housing vouchers, regardless…

  • The Elephant in the Room

    Housing activists frequently proclaim that a household earning the minimum wage cannot afford a two-bedroom apartment. This is the elephant in the room that housing activists refuse to address. As an example, the executive director of the Capital Area Housing Partnership in Michigan writes, The fair market rent for a modest two-bedroom apartment in the…

  • Wanna Bet?

    The recent Supreme Court ruling striking down a federal law that prohibited most states from allowing betting on sporting events was a double-edged sword. While it struck down a right-violating law, it will do nothing to prevent states from violating individual rights. According to CNN, The court said the federal law violated constitutional principles limiting…

  • Vaccine Imperialism

    For months, there have been increasing demands for waivers for the intellectual property rights to COVID vaccines. Big Pharma, the argument goes, should share its knowledge and technology with anyone who desires it. To refuse to do so is “vaccine imperialism.” The failure to waive intellectual property rights is being blamed for the low vaccination…