Friday Roundup 11-12-21

ByBrian Phillips

City council members in Denver recently became the latest legislative body to demonstrate that a basic knowledge of economics is not necessary to hold an elected office. The council is considering a proposal to require that all new housing developments include below market-rate units in the project. The proposal would also increase the “affordable housing fee” from the current range of $0.44 to $1.86 per square foot to $4 to $8 per square foot. These costs will be passed on to renters and home buyers in the form of higher housing prices. Yet, council members believe that somehow this measure will make housing more affordable.

Last week, California’s Attorney General, Rob Bonta, announced a task force that will pressure local governments to build more housing. The state’s Department of Housing and Community Developments sets the number of new housing units each region is projected to need for all income levels, and many regions aren’t coming close to meeting these needs. Sadly, Bonta is following the same framework that created the housing crisis in California. The state’s restrictive land-use and environmental regulations drive up the cost of housing. Those strong-arm restrict the actions of individuals for the “common good.” Bonta wants to use strong-arm measures to force jurisdictions to build more housing. Whether he means it literally or not, he is framing the issue in an incorrect manner. Instead of forcing municipalities to build more housing, he should be defending the freedom of housing producers to build more housing.

A bill has been introduced to the Massachusetts legislature that will “allow communities to slow displacement and gentrification by removing some homes from the for-profit, speculative market.” The Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act would give the tenants of multi-family housing the opportunity to purchase their home when the owner wants to sell. The measure would also allow tenants to assign this “right” to the municipality or a non-profit. If only a portion of the tenants exercise one of these options, the owner is going to own only a part of the building. This will make it extremely difficult to sell the other units and force the owner into a partnership with his former tenants.

Similar Posts

  • Those Who don’t Learn from History…

    ByBrian Phillips

    Swedish economist Assar Lindbeck once asserted, “In many cases rent control appears to be the most efficient technique presently known to destroy a city—except for bombing.” Economists disagree on many things, but almost universally agree that rent control is a bad idea. But this hasn’t stopped politicians and housing advocates from calling for more rent…

  • |

    The Roundup 11

    ByBrian Phillips

    As the destruction caused by lock downs continues to grow, housing advocates have called for numerous measures to protect tenants, including rent control. And while economists have long agreed that rent control is destructive to the housing market, that hasn’t stopped politicians from catering to “tenants’ rights” groups. As an example, in Spain, a law…

  • A Lesson from Road Subsidies

    ByBrian Phillips

    In the early twentieth century the Good Roads movement successfully framed improved roads as a “public good.” Better roads, the movement argued, would enable food and manufactured products to be more easily distributed and everyone would benefit. Therefore, free, improved roads should be provided by government. Today, housing advocates are making a similar argument. If…

  • A Flawed Framework

    Byjbp

    As I point out in my book, The Affordable Housing Crisis: Causes and Cures, for more than one hundred years housing policy has been dominated by the same flawed framework. Each “new” housing policy simply repeats policies that have previously failed. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is an example. He ran on a promise…

  • Friday Roundup 8-6-21

    ByBrian Phillips

    Barry Fagin, a Senior Fellow at the Independence Institute in Denver, correctly notes that conservatives are very confused about the meaning of property rights. As examples, he cites Florida Gov. Rick DeSantis’ ban of “vaccine passports” and conservative calls to regulate social media companies like Facebook and Twitter. Fagin concludes that property rights have fallen…

  • |

    Less than Ideal

    ByBrian Phillips

    In October 2020, the Cambridge, Massachusetts, city council enacted a citywide 100 percent affordable housing overly (AHO). The AHO allows apartment buildings up to four stories in all neighborhoods in the city. However, all units must be permanently affordable to households earning up to 100% of area median income. The standard for affordability is paying…